OpenAI Challenges Apple’s Security Claims in Trade Secrets Lawsuit

The defense filing centers on the assertion that Apple’s internal data management is too disorganized to support allegations of theft. OpenAI points to instances where an Apple manager remained logged into the personal iCloud account of former engineer Chang Liu after his departure, even requesting technical assistance on Apple projects. This suggests that the information in question was not handled with the rigorous confidentiality required for trade secret protection.

Furthermore, OpenAI characterizes the lawsuit as a strategic maneuver designed to stifle competition rather than a genuine effort to protect intellectual property. The motion contends that Apple failed to identify specific stolen trade secrets, relying instead on vague categories like product testing and supplier relationships. OpenAI maintains that its rapid growth in AI hardware attracts top talent who are disillusioned with Apple’s internal pace, suggesting the litigation is a pretextual response to Apple’s broader struggles in the AI talent market.